As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you click through and make a purchase.
| Spec | Magic Mill 7-Tray Stainless Steel Dehydrator | Cercker 12-Tray Food Dehydrator |
|---|---|---|
| Tray Count | 7 trays | 12 trays |
| Drying Area | – | 10.9ft² |
| Wattage | – | 800W |
| Temperature Range | – | 70℉–190℉ |
| Timer Duration | – | 24 hours |
| Tray Material | Stainless steel | Stainless steel |
| Use | Fruit | Fruit |
| Cooking Functions | Keep Warm | – |
| Features | Timer, Keep Warm Setting | Timer |
| Color | Stainless Steel | Silvery |
| Intended Use | Meats | Meats |
| Recommended Uses | Fruits | Fruits |
| Cooking Function | – | Yogurt |
| Timer | – | 24-Hour Timer |
| Dimensions | 15 × 13.5 × 19 inches | 12.4 × 16.5 × 17.7 inches |
| Weight | 16.7 pounds | – |
| Size | 7 XL Trays | 12 trays |
| Model | MFD-7070 | CE-12 |
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
When comparing the magic mill vs cercker food dehydrator, you will find two stainless steel machines built for even drying. Both models feature rear-mounted fans and digital controls. The main difference lies in capacity and power. The Magic Mill offers seven trays with a keep warm function. The Cercker provides twelve trays and an 800-watt motor. You should choose based on your volume needs and desired drying speed.
Tray Count
7 trays
12 trays
Wattage
not listed
800W
Temperature Range
adjustable
70℉–190℉
Timer Duration
countdown with auto shut off
24 hours
Dimensions
13.5 x 19 x 15 inches
16.5 x 17.7 x 12.4 inches
Choose the first if
- You prefer a more compact footprint for limited counter space.
- You want a keep warm function to hold finished food.
- You need fewer trays for small batches of jerky or herbs.
Choose the second if
- You need to dry large volumes of food in a single batch.
- You want precise temperature control with 5℉ increments.
- You prefer a higher wattage motor for faster drying cycles.
Verdict
The Magic Mill suits users who prioritize space efficiency and a keep warm feature for smaller batches. The Cercker is better for those who need high capacity and precise, high-power drying. Choose the model that aligns with your typical batch size.
Magic Mill vs Cercker Specs
capacity and size
Edge: Tie
The Magic Mill Pro features seven extra-large stainless steel trays, offering a substantial drying surface for bulk batches. Its dimensions are 13.5 inches wide, 15 inches long, and 19 inches high, weighing 16.7 pounds. The Cercker model provides twelve trays, doubling the tray count compared to the Magic Mill. It measures 16.5 inches wide, 12.4 inches long, and 17.7 inches high. The Cercker specifies a drying area of 10.9 square feet. While the Magic Mill focuses on extra-large individual tray size, the Cercker maximizes total layer count within a slightly wider footprint. You choose based on whether you prefer fewer, larger trays or more, smaller ones.
temperature control
Edge: Cercker 12-Tray Food Dehydrator
Both units use digital thermostats for precise heat management. The Cercker offers a wider temperature range, adjustable from 70°F to 190°F in 5°F increments. This broad span allows for delicate drying of herbs at lower temperatures and robust jerky preparation at higher heat. The Magic Mill lists an adjustable temperature control but does not specify the exact minimum or maximum degrees or the increment steps in the provided data. Both machines ensure even heat distribution through rear-mounted fans. The Cercker’s explicit range gives you more defined control options for different food types right from the start.
timer and automation
Edge: Tie
The Cercker includes a 24-hour timer with 0.5-hour increments, providing detailed scheduling for long drying cycles. It features an intelligent shutdown that activates immediately when the timer ends. The Magic Mill also has a countdown timer with automatic shut-off and a keep-warm function to maintain food temperature after drying. This keep-warm setting is a unique feature not listed for the Cercker. Both models prevent overcooking by stopping automatically. If you need extended drying times with half-hour precision, the Cercker is superior. If you want to hold finished food warm immediately after the cycle, the Magic Mill is the better choice.
power and airflow
Edge: Cercker 12-Tray Food Dehydrator
The Cercker specifies an 800-watt motor with a rear two-row drying fan. It reports an air circulation speed of 2 meters per second at 1600 RPM, aiming for efficient and even heat distribution. The Magic Mill also uses a rear-mounted fan with air flow circulation technology to ensure even drying without needing to rotate shelves. However, the Magic Mill data does not list its wattage, fan speed, or specific airflow metrics. The Cercker provides transparent technical details about its power and circulation speed, allowing you to gauge its drying intensity more accurately than the unspecified specs of the Magic Mill.
included accessories
Edge: Cercker 12-Tray Food Dehydrator
The Magic Mill includes fruit roll trays, mesh trays for small items like nuts and herbs, and a fruit leather sheet that can double as a drip tray. All trays are dishwasher safe. The Cercker comes with twelve stainless steel trays that are also dishwasher safe. Additionally, the Cercker package includes a recipe book, a door handle, a drip tray, silicone gloves, a screwdriver, and a user manual. The Magic Mill highlights its specific drying sheets for versatility, while the Cercker provides a broader set of tools and accessories for setup and maintenance. You get more physical extras with the Cercker.
safety and noise
Edge: Cercker 12-Tray Food Dehydrator
Both dehydrators prioritize safety with intelligent overheat protection that activates if internal temperatures become too high. The Magic Mill emphasizes its BPA-free food-grade stainless steel construction. The Cercker also uses 100% BPA-free stainless steel and notes that a slight odor is normal initially. The Cercker explicitly states a noise level of 50 dB or less, making it a quiet option for home use. The Magic Mill data does not mention its decibel rating. Both models ensure safe operation through thermal cutoffs. The Cercker provides specific noise data, which is helpful for kitchen placement, while the Magic Mill focuses on material safety.
Which Dehydrator Fits Your Needs
Users needing large capacity and fast drying
Our pick: Cercker 12-Tray Food Dehydrator
The Cercker model provides twelve stainless steel trays and an 800W motor, offering more drying space and higher power than the Magic Mill. Its 10.9 square feet of drying area handles bulk batches efficiently. The rear-mounted dual-row fan ensures even heat distribution across all layers for consistent results.
Buyers wanting keep warm functionality
Our pick: Magic Mill 7-Tray Stainless Steel Dehydrator
The Magic Mill includes a dedicated keep warm setting, which the Cercker does not list. This feature allows you to maintain the temperature of dehydrated food after the cycle ends. You can set the timer and let the machine hold the heat, keeping jerky or fruits ready to eat without additional steps.
Those prioritizing a longer warranty
Our pick: Cercker 12-Tray Food Dehydrator
Cercker backs its dehydrator with a three-year warranty, providing longer coverage than the Magic Mill. This extended protection covers the motor and internal components. You get peace of mind knowing that support is available for a longer period if any issues arise with the stainless steel trays or digital thermostat.
Magic Mill 7-Tray Stainless Steel Dehydrator
Best for: Small batch drying with even heat distribution
- Tray Count
- 7 trays
- Tray Material
- Stainless steel
- Use
- Fruit
- Cooking Functions
- Keep Warm
- Features
- Timer, Keep Warm Setting
- Intended Use
- Meats
The Magic Mill MFD-7070 features seven XL stainless steel trays for drying meats, fruits, and herbs. Its rear-mounted fan ensures even heat distribution without needing to rotate shelves. A digital thermostat and timer allow precise control, including a keep-warm function. Weighing 16.7 pounds, it offers a spacious 13.5 by 15 by 19-inch footprint for batch drying.
- Rear-mounted fan for superior heat distribution
- Seven XL stainless steel trays included
- Digital thermostat with countdown timer
- Keep warm function for finished food
- Transparent door window for monitoring
- Lower tray count than the 12-tray competitor
- Heavier build at 16.7 pounds
- Fixed 800W power limit compared to higher-wattage models
- You need even drying without rotating trays
- You want a keep-warm function for finished batches
- You prefer stainless steel trays for easy cleaning
- You require more than seven trays for large batches
- You prefer a lighter unit under 15 pounds
- You need a compact unit under 14 inches tall
Verdict: Magic Mill 7-Tray Food Dehydrator fits users who prioritize even heat distribution and a keep-warm function over maximum capacity. It is a solid choice for small to medium batches of jerky or herbs.
Cercker 12-Tray Food Dehydrator
Best for: Large batches of dried fruits and meats
- Tray Count
- 12 trays
- Drying Area
- 10.9ft²
- Wattage
- 800W
- Temperature Range
- 70℉–190℉
- Timer Duration
- 24 hours
- Tray Material
- Stainless steel
This Cercker dehydrator features 12 stainless steel trays providing 10.9 square feet of drying space. The 800W motor supports temperatures from 70°F to 190°F with 5°F increments. You get a 24-hour timer and an electronic thermostat for precise control. The unit measures 16.5 by 17.7 inches and operates at under 50 dB. It is designed for drying fruits, meats, and making yogurt efficiently.
- 12 stainless steel trays offer 10.9 square feet of drying area
- Adjustable temperature range from 70°F to 190°F in 5°F increments
- 24-hour timer with 0.5-hour increments for precise scheduling
- Operates at low noise levels of 50 dB or less
- 800W wattage is lower than the 1000W or higher options available in this category
- 10.9 square feet of drying area is less than the 11.5 square feet offered by the Magic Mill Pro
- Fixed dimensions of 16.5 by 17.7 inches limit countertop footprint flexibility
- You need a large capacity for drying multiple batches of food at once
- You want precise temperature control for sensitive items like yogurt or herbs
- You prefer quiet operation with noise levels under 50 dB
- You require the maximum possible drying area available in this guide
- You need higher wattage for faster drying times
- You prefer a more compact unit with fewer trays
Verdict: Cercker 12-Tray Food Dehydrator provides ample space and precise controls for serious home drying projects. It suits you best if you prioritize capacity and quiet operation over raw power or maximum surface area.
Specifications side by side
Frequently asked questions
Which dehydrator is better for making jerky?
The Magic Mill is a strong choice for meat drying. It includes a keep-warm setting that helps maintain safe temperatures for meats. The Cercker also supports meat use but lacks this specific feature in its listed attributes. If you prioritize temperature consistency for jerky, the Magic Mill’s keep-warm function offers an advantage over the Cercker.
Does the Cercker dehydrator have a timer?
Yes, the Cercker includes a 24-hour timer. This allows you to set long drying cycles for fruits or meats without manual monitoring. The Magic Mill also features a timer, but the Cercker’s specific 24-hour capacity provides extended automation. This is useful for overnight drying projects where precise timing is essential for food safety.
Can I make yogurt in the Cercker dehydrator?
Yes, the Cercker lists yogurt as a cooking function. This indicates it can maintain the low, steady heat required for fermentation. The Magic Mill does not list yogurt as a function, focusing instead on keep-warm for meats and fruits. If yogurt making is a priority, the Cercker’s specific function setting makes it the suitable option.
How tall is the Magic Mill dehydrator?
The Magic Mill stands 19 inches high. This vertical dimension accommodates its seven extra-large trays stacked vertically. The Cercker is shorter at 17.7 inches, though it holds more trays due to a different internal layout. Consider your cabinet clearance, as the Magic Mill requires more vertical space than the Cercker model.
Is the Magic Mill dehydrator stainless steel?
Yes, the Magic Mill features a stainless steel construction. This material is durable and easy to clean. The Cercker is described as silvery, which often indicates a plastic or coated finish, though the trays may be stainless. For a fully stainless steel exterior, the Magic Mill is the clear choice based on its published specifications.
Which model is lighter and easier to move?
The Magic Mill weighs 16.7 pounds. The Cercker’s weight is not specified in the data, so a direct comparison is limited. However, the Magic Mill’s weight is moderate for a seven-tray unit. If you need to move the unit frequently, the Magic Mill’s known weight helps you plan storage and transport logistics effectively.
